Posted on
Rate this post

Whether you like mushrooms, mushrooms, or beef, you’ll probably be on the edge of your seat for this one! Since Porcini mushroom grows only in the winter and autumn, there will Constantly be a severe shortage beyond its season, necessitating the knowledge of various Porcini mushroom replacements.

Yet with the way this mushroom tastes, the enticing perfume, and the meaty texture, many people may succumb! But, the Porcini mushroom is not the only popular fungus that may be used in your dishes.

Several cool porcini mushroom replacements, such as shiitake mushroom, portobello mushroom, oyster mushroom, button mushroom, cremini mushroom, and so on, may help you forget or miss the Porcini less, particularly if you use them in risotto, gravies, and soups.

What Is Porcini Mushrooms? 

Porcini Mushroom (Boletus edulis) is a kind of edible fungus that may be found fresh or dried.

This component is quite popular across the Northern Hemisphere, including North America, Europe, and Asia. It is infrequently seen in the Southern Hemisphere, however it may be found in Australia, southern Africa, New Zealand, and Brazil.

Porcini mushrooms have a woodsy and earthy aroma and provide a meaty texture as well as a punch of umami flavor to any meal. It grows from tiny to enormous proportions, with a spherical crown that averages 7-30 centimeters in diameter and a fairly thick stem.

They’re also a versatile ingredient in our cuisines. Besides from soups and stews, here are more common ways to include Porcini into your diet:

  • Make homemade pizza with it.
  • Eat it sautéed, fried, or with eggs.
  • Salads with chopped porcini mushrooms
  • Mushrooms may be used in spaghetti sauce.
  • Incorporated into cooked meat, turkey, or chicken
  • As a side dish, cook it with garlic and butter.
  • Pizza toppings
  • Include in a stir-fry with other veggies.

Benefits Of Using Porcini Mushrooms

Porcini Mushrooms are well-known for their great health advantages in addition to being a pleasant and fragrant ingredient.

It is high in key vitamins and minerals, making it a nutritious complement to your diet.

Best Porcini Mushroom Substitutes

Don’t be concerned. We have hand-picked ONLY the finest selections, which include portobello mushrooms and Shiitake mushrooms, which are the closest thing to Porcini mushrooms.

1. Portobello Mushrooms

Portobello Mushrooms are the mushroom’s Goliath, growing to be larger than your palm when left to mature.

The spherical, flat top is roughly fifteen centimeters in diameter, hard, thin, and spongy, and linked to a stout stem. Don’t assume for a second that they’re huge for nothing. Though this mushroom is large, it is exactly the idea because just two to three pieces will enough for your recipes.

When Porcini are unavailable, Portobello Mushrooms are nearly universally preferred. It has a meaty, juicy texture and a moderate umami taste that complements any cuisine, similar to the Porcini mushroom.

What’s the greatest part?

Portabella mushrooms are available all year and at practically every grocery. It is also high in vitamin D, vitamin B6, copper, selenium, phosphorus, and niacin.

They are, however, better suited for cooked applications such as sautéing, broiling, and grilling. It may be hollowed out and cooked whole to produce a veggie burger.

They may also be chopped and used into stews and soups, or baked into pasta and rice recipes. You would love them cut into salads, among other things.

2. Shiitake Mushroom 

If you are short of Porcini mushrooms, you should use Shiitake Mushrooms since they are the closest replacement you can acquire.

Shiitake mushrooms have the EXACT SAME TEXTURE and APPEARANCE as porcini mushrooms, but they have a greater meaty taste, are less earthy, and have short, non-edible stems.

Besides from that, use this Porcini twin to get that umami, fragrant taste.

You may even substitute these mushrooms for equivalent amounts in any meal, including stews, gravies, risotto, soups, pies, and others. They are also nutritious and nutritious.

3. Button Mushroom

Button is a draft mushroom that is smaller and less meaty in texture, as the name implies.

They are seasonal, like Porcini, and are cultivated in climate-controlled cropping rooms. So don’t be disheartened. They have that umami, earthy flavor as well and are really adaptable.

They are less costly than Porcini mushrooms and are the most often seen in supermarkets. That means they may be used in any Porcini dish at any time. But, since they are smaller in size, bear in mind that you will need to use more of them for replacement.

4. Oyster Mushroom

The oyster mushroom is another popular edible fungus known for its characteristic oyster appearance. This mushroom is both beautiful and tasty, which is an apt description.

Kennett Mushrooms, on the other hand, reigns supreme when it comes to the most beautiful and unusual mushrooms in the earth.

We have included our delectable Oyster mushrooms among our top selections because of its meaty texture and umami taste, similar to Porcini.

The texture in your mouth feels like chicken, and they work great with any cuisine. You may use them in stews and soups, sauces, stir-fry dishes, and even as a pizza topping. They are, nevertheless, extremely expensive, yet widely accessible in all supermarkets.

5. Chanterelle Mushroom 

Another good substitute for Porcini are Chanterelle mushrooms, which look similar to oyster mushrooms and have an earthy, meaty flavor.

Its motto is similarly “umami taste,” yet chanterelle is distinct on its own. Unlike Porcini and many of the other mushrooms on this list, which taste like beef gravy, chanterelles have a moderately peppery flavor and a fruity aroma similar to apricots.

Unfortunately, dried chanterelle loses much of its luster following rehydration. Many home chefs prefer fresh mushrooms, which taste fantastic in any dish that calls for mushrooms. Chanterelle works well in soups, fried dishes, sautéed vegetables, stews, and other dishes.

6. Cremini Mushrooms

Cremini resembles the Button Mushroom. They are likewise dwarfish, but have a meaty texture and umami taste similar to Porcini. Since Cremini mushrooms are accessible all year, it’s a perfect replacement.

Hence, if Porcini is out of season, you may use Cremini instead. Moreover, they are high in potassium, vitamin D, selenium, amino acids, riboflavin, zinc, phosphorus, folate, and manganese.

This mushroom’s uses are almost unlimited, since it is suitable for both raw and cooked applications such as stewing, roasting, baking, or sautéing.

You may use them raw in grain dishes or salads, or fill them with cheese, crab, and meats for a bite-sized appetizer. They are also delicious in sauces, soups, and as a pizza topping.

Other Porcini Mushrooms Alternatives That Might Work 

If you’re simply interested in the porcini flavor and not the meaty texture, you may want to look into these alternative porcini mushroom replacements.

We isolated these alternatives from the others.

7. Dried Thyme

Doesn’t it sound strange? Yet, dried thyme is one of the greatest dried porcini mushroom substitutes.

Forget about the chewy section once again. Thyme, like dried Porcini, has an earthy, somewhat spicy taste. And keep in mind that mushrooms are often cooked with thyme to enhance the taste.

8. Tomato Paste

In the absence of Porcini, tomato paste will suffice for stews, soups, and sauces. Tomato paste is thick and has a wonderful savory umami taste.

But, keep in mind that you are also embracing a tomato touch, so it is not suited for sautéing.

9. Soy Sauce

Soy sauce is well-known for its umami taste. As a result, use this seasoning in Porcini-flavored soups, sauces, and stews.

Just add a few dashes of soy sauce and a pinch of salt, since this sauce is very salty.

10. Dried Truffles

Dried Truffles are the last option on our list of Porcini mushroom substitutes.

Truffles have an earthy umami flavor, yet they may taste somewhat different from one another. They may, however, continue to hold the fort for Porcini mushrooms. At the very least, they’re chewy.

Frequently Asked Question

What Can I Use Instead Of Dried Porcini Mushrooms?

Dried truffles, soy sauce, thyme, and tomato paste will all match the same taste profile since they all have strong umami flavor.

Each of these choices is readily available and reasonably priced at your local retailers. Although they may not have the same meaty taste, they will provide almost the same depth of flavor to your recipes.

Where Are Dried Porcini Mushrooms In The Grocery Store?

Dried Porcini mushrooms may be obtained at stores that sell dry or dehydrated goods.

In addition, depending on the grocery store, they are often located near the pasta aisle. At some stores, they are only found in the Asian aisle and are not near the fresh ones since they may stay longer.

Are Dried Porcini Mushrooms The Same As Fresh?

They are, but they each have their fair share of apathy. Dried porcini mushrooms, for example, have a harder texture and a more concentrated umami taste than fresh ones.

They are often cut before drying and must be rehydrated with warm water before use. Fresh porcini mushrooms, on the other hand, may be cooked immediately.

Can I Substitute Fresh Mushrooms For Dried?

In most circumstances, you can use both interchangeably. It makes little difference, particularly in soup or risotto, as long as you rehydrate it for a few hours before using.

In the recipe, substitute one pound of fresh Porcini with three ounces of dried Porcini. I realize that seems insufficient, but they will offer you a pound of fresh Porcini once they have expanded.


That concludes our list of the finest porcini mushroom replacements. Porcini, unlike other mushrooms, are mycorrhizal, and cultivation may be difficult owing to their complicated link with their environment.

It may be difficult to find them fresh depending on where you live. Even if you do, it will be costly. Some of these options are not mushrooms, but they taste similar to Porcini.

Some, on the other hand, may be mushrooms but lack the powerful mushroomy taste and meatiness of Porcini. As a result, we propose portobello and Shiitake mushrooms as our top options. These are, once again, the closest thing to a Porcini mushroom.

Suggested Articles:

  • Does Dill Go Well With Mushrooms?
  • Does Rosemary Go Well With Mushrooms?
  • What Herbs Go Well With Mushroom?
  • Are Button Mushroom Gills Consumable?


What can I replace porcini mushroom with?

Shiitake mushrooms are said to be the greatest alternative for dried porcini mushrooms. This substitute is ideal for practically any dish due to its comparable taste and texture.

Can I substitute chanterelle for porcini?

Chanterelles are a milder alternative to porcini mushrooms. This does not imply that they are mild, since they are also umami-rich! It does, however, imply that they give less flavor to broths or mushroom sauces. To match the umami flavor of the porcini, increase the amount slightly.

What type of dried mushroom is best?

Shiitake mushrooms are among the most popular dried mushrooms on the market, since they complement a wide range of meals. This mushroom is delicious as a stand-alone ingredient as well as in stocks, gravies, and stir-fries.

Does shiitake taste like porcini?

Porcini mushrooms vs.

Porcini mushrooms are often mistaken with shiitake mushrooms. These mushrooms are widely available in dried and rehydrated forms for use in broths, soups, and sauces. Shiitake mushrooms have a meatier flavor with less earthy mushroom flavor and are less expensive than porcini mushrooms.

What is the alternative name for porcini?

Boletus edulis (also known as cep, penny bun, porcino, or porcini) is the type species of the genus Boletus.

Are there porcini look alikes?

“In the Northeast, one porcini look-alike has been linked to various illnesses.” It’s called Boletus huronensis, and although some guides say it’s edible, there have been a few reports of people becoming ill after eating it.

What is the difference between porcini and Boletus?

Porcini mushrooms are also members of the Boletus genus. The phrase “porcini” usually refers to the species Boletus edulis, which is also known by a variety of other names. Boletus edulis thrives in woodland habitats and is a popular, tasty wild mushroom that is difficult to produce.

What edible mushroom is also known as porcini?

Boletus edulis, sometimes known as porcini, cep, Steinpilz, or penny bun mushrooms, is a fresh or dried edible fungus. Porcini mushrooms are used in recipes for Italian pasta and rice dishes, soups and sauces, and savory specialities like risotto for their earthy, meaty taste.

Which is the best tasty mushroom in the world?

Shiitake mushrooms are one of the world’s most popular mushrooms, and with good reason. They are well-known for their rich, savory flavor and several health advantages. This mushroom is indigenous to Japan. Shiitake is a Japanese word that meaning “oak fungus.” Shiitake mushrooms have a subtle woodsy flavor and scent when fresh.

What is the most delicious mushroom?

Black Trumpet is one of seven mushroom varieties to look for. Bret Bunyard, skilled forager and editor-in-chief of Fungi Magazine, recommends black trumpet mushrooms.
… Chicken of the Woods…. Lion’s Mane…. Maitake (also known as Hen-of-the-Wood)… Morels…. Shiitake…. Wood Ear.
Sep 28, 2021

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *