Posted on
Rate this post

Today’s theme is devoted to the yellow mustard, the legendary hero of America’s classic hot dog condiment. This mustard is a must-have condiment for hot dogs, pretzels, sandwiches, and hamburgers, as well as salad dressings, potato salads, and barbecue sauces.

The crisp, acidic, and tangy taste will not irritate anyone’s sinuses with spice, which is why everyone enjoys it as a garnish for foods. Today, however, we will not be extolling its praises, but rather proposing options in the event of an emergency.

German mustard, English mustard, Dijon mustard, honey mustard, spicy mustard, and homemade yellow mustard are all excellent yellow mustard replacements.

Best Yellow Mustard Substitutes

1. Dijon Mustard

Can’t produce yellow mustard on your own?

You may use this traditional French mustard, but be prepared for some heat.

Despite not made from yellow mustard seed, Dijon and yellow mustard have a similar smooth consistency but distinct hues and flavors.

Dijon mustard has a sharper, more nuanced taste profile and a light yellow tint, as opposed to yellow mustard’s brilliant yellow.

Also, since less vinegar is used, it is somewhat creamy and pasty, with nearly no watery foundation.

There must be a lot of distinctions between Dijon and yellow mustard, right? Maybe, but this mustard is used interchangeably in practically all mustard recipes.

2. Spicy Mustard

The third option is a hotter variation produced with slightly ground yellow and brown mustard seeds.

This results in a mottled brownish-yellow tint. Spicy brown mustard has a stronger taste and a rougher texture than Dijon or yellow mustard.

It is quite popular in the United States, particularly among New York hotdog vendors.

You may also cook with it, preparing sauces, marinades, and topping bagels. Some delis would gladly mix it with horseradish for added zing.

Yet, you should be aware of its tangy, robust taste. As a result, you should use less of it.

3. English Mustard

Hot English mustard combines Dijon and yellow mustard.

This hot mustard goes well with sauces, casseroles, mayonnaise, vinaigrettes, gravies, meat roasts, sandwiches, and other dishes.

You may also spread the mustard powder on chicken, meat, fish, or pork before cooking.

While it appears identical to American mustard, it is thicker and spicier.

4. German Mustard

German mustard is also somewhat hotter than yellow mustard and Dijon mustard. It also comprises a mixture of partly crushed and whole mustard seeds, giving it a rougher texture.

Nonetheless, there are other varieties of German mustard that are prominent in German cuisine: Senfkrner has a whole seed basis and is best used to season sauces and meat.

Meanwhile, Senfpulver is a dry powder variant that is great for cooking, whilst Senf is a pasty variety that is the most popular and can meet all of your yellow mustard demands.

Senf, on the other hand, comes in two flavors: Bavarian Sweet and Dsseldorf.

The Dsseldorf Senf has a sweet and sour taste note comparable to yellow mustard but is most known for its usage with a meal called Mostertpttche.

All German mustard, however, is prepared using brown mustard seeds, spices, and vinegar.

They all seem to go well with hot dogs, sausages, baked pretzels, meats, and wursts.

5. Honey Mustard

Finally on our list is the sweetest mustard, which is notably sweeter than yellow mustard and serves as an excellent substitute for chicken and pork.

This mustard is rich of warm spices and sweetened with honey. They’re also great in dips, marinades, sauces, and pig rubs.

Most people love it on sandwiches or ham because of its sweet, tangy flavor.

You can also blend it with olive oil or vinegar to make a delicious dressing for vegetables and salads.

6. Homemade Yellow Mustard

Making your own yellow mustard is the greatest replacement. You may believe that making mustard from scratch is virtually difficult. But it’s much simpler since you’ll be done in under 45 minutes.

The only difficult step is determining the correct measurements for each item.

Furthermore, a non-reactive pot!

If you check these boxes, I can tell you that you can make a VERY excellent yellow mustard with the same crisp, acidic, and tangy taste as the branded version.

Let’s skip the boring small talk and let me turn you into a mustard chef.

How To Make Yellow Mustard (step-by-step guide)


  • saucepan that is non-reactive


  • 1 cup ice water
  • 4 cup dried yellow mustard3
  • 4 tsp. kosher salt3
  • 1 paprika teaspoon
  • 1 tsp garlic powder or 1 tsp garlic pure1
  • 1 teaspoon turmeric powder
  • 1 cup distilled white vinegar


Before you begin, make sure you’re cooking in a well-ventilated kitchen.

Additionally, a non-reactive pot is required to keep the recipes from coloring.

Step 1: Begin Adding Ingredients.

Please clean the nonstick saucepan and put 1 cup of water in it over low to medium heat.

Apart for the vinegar, mix together all of the components (ground turmeric, garlic, paprika, salt, yellow mustard powder) until smooth. Let it to cook for 30 to 45 minutes. Continue to stir until it bubbles and thickens to a paste.

Step 2: Pour in the White Distilled Vinegar

After it’s pasty, add your cup of white distilled vinegar and heat until it thickens to a real mustard consistency.

With steady whisking, this should take around 10 to 15 minutes.

Step 3: Let It to Cool.

After you’ve reached the proper consistency, let it to cool to room temperature. The mustard should then be spooned into an airtight container, covered, and refrigerated.

It’s common for mustard to taste hot in the first few days or weeks. It will, however, soften over time.

You may keep the mustard in the fridge for up to three months after using it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Yellow Mustard Used For?

Most people only associate yellow mustard on hot dogs with the summer season, when the dewy summer air is pleasant and the days are long and full of promises.

The magnificent hot dog season normally lasts from June through September.

But now that we’re in the autumn or winter season, are you going to let your mustard sit in the fridge?

Absolutely not!

Yellow mustard may also be used in sandwiches, hamburgers, pretzels, salad dressings, barbecue sauces, and numerous potato salads.

How Many Kinds Of Mustard Are There?

When it comes to mustard seeds, there are just three main varieties: yellow, brown, and black. Each has its own distinct taste and amount of heat.

If you’re talking about the variations created from these seeds, you won’t be short of possibilities.

There are around 15 mustard varieties, maybe more, some of which we have previously explored as part of our yellow mustard alternative.

And the kind of seeds, processing, and liquids utilized all have a substantial impact on these variations. They are as follows:

  • Mustard from Germany
  • Mustard (England)
  • Baseball mustard in the United States
  • Mustard Mustard Dijon
  • Sweet Mustard from Bavaria
  • Mustard from Dsseldorf
  • Mustard Horseradish
  • Mustard, Whole Grain
  • Mustard Mustard Honey
  • Cajun Mustard
  • Mustard with a Fiery Kick
  • Mustard (China Mustard)
  • Mustard Mustard Fruit
  • Mustard with Spicy Peppers
  • Mustard Beer

What Is The Hottest Mustard?

The hottest mustard is black seeded mustard. These are the most vicious, therefore STAY AWAY if you can’t stand the heat!

While any mustard (even back mustard) is impotent in powdered form, it lacks potency.

The heat, however, is shown by the creation of Allyl isothiocyanate from the interaction of sinigrin and myrosinase.

Why Is Mustard The Best Condiment?

I can’t promise that mustard is the finest condiment on the earth.

Have you ever heard of Pesto, Salsa, Tahini, Kimchi, Hummus, or Sauerkraut?

All of these condiments are pleasant and healthful. So mustard isn’t the only one who has been picked.

Yet, it, like the others, is extremely low in carbs and calories (about 5 calories in one teaspoon). Yet, although being fat-free, it adds a peppery spice to dishes.


All of these yellow mustard replacements are very customizable to your specific requirements.

But, the heat level may be adjusted to your liking, ranging from sweet to moderate to flaming.

That is why, if you have an undying passion for yellow mustard, we suggest producing your own.

If not, you may just use whatever choice is offered to you. But, it is better to stick to what is similar to your favorite yellow mustard.



What can I replace yellow mustard with?

Yellow Mustard Alternative
Mixture of dry mustard: Use 12 teaspoon dry mustard + 2 teaspoons water for 1 tablespoon yellow mustard.
Use a different kind of mustard: Yellow mustard may be replaced with Dijon or honey mustard.
Sep 29, 2022

What is the closest mustard to yellow mustard?

Mustard, either yellow or stone-ground.

Dijon is the closest taste match to the powder, but both work. The conversion is the same: 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard Equals 1 teaspoon dry mustard.

What tastes like mustard substitute?

If you’re in a hurry, turmeric is a fantastic dry spice to have on hand. It has the same brilliant yellow hue as dry mustard and a comparable taste. But, since turmeric is less spicy, it will not provide as much flavor. When you’re short of dry mustard, use it as a 1:1 substitute.

Can I substitute Dijon mustard for yellow mustard?

The two are quite similar, and a 1:1 swap is possible. Yellow mustard is prepared from white mustard seeds and then colored with turmeric. Dijon mustard is more acidic and spicy than yellow mustard, which is milder. Yet, the taste change is minimal.

What color is closest to mustard yellow?

The hue is a dark yellow that recalls culinary mustard. It resembles the color flax. Mustard is a boring condiment.

Why does yellow mustard taste so different?

The amount of heat in a mustard is strongly proportional to the kind of seed utilized. Yellow mustard seeds (also known as white mustard seeds) are the mildest, whereas brown and black mustard seeds are significantly hotter and more aromatic. Yet, the liquid used to wet the seeds and bind the mustard has a significant influence on its pungency.

Why is yellow mustard hard to find?

What is the cause of the mustard scarcity? To blame are climate change and the Ukraine-Russia supply network. Canada is the world’s leading mustard seed harvester, and its mustard output fell 28% in 2021 owing to excessive heat and severe droughts.

What is the closest mustard to American?

Yellow Mustard, sometimes known as “American Mustard,” derives its vivid yellow color from turmeric.

What kind of mustard do Italians use?

Sweet fruits are used in Italian fruit mustard (mostarda di frutta). The Italian version of mustard is mostarda di frutta. Italians add delicious fruits like figs and cherries drenched in sugar and honey to their mustard complex with a note of sweetness, in addition to the standard components of mustard seeds and vinegar.

What can I use in place of prepared mustard?

What is a Mustard Substitute Prepared? When a recipe asks for prepared mustard, substitute 1 teaspoon dry mustard (ground mustard) for 1 tablespoon prepared mustard, and replace the missing liquid with the same quantity of water or vinegar.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *