8 Best Substitutes for Thick Whipping Cream

When you add a dollop of heavy whipping cream to your supper, you already know what time it is. Things are going to get smooth and delectable.

From custardy desserts, sauces, ganache, delicious spaghetti sauce, vanilla ice cream, to soups and baked products, heavy cream thickens and adds a wonderful touch. But what if you run out of ingredients in the midst of a recipe?

However, substituting whole milk will not suffice since it is lighter and has less fat. I’m presuming you want something with the consistency of heavy cream that you can use right away.

Have you ever tried using milk and butter in a pinch? There is a foolproof approach to replace heavy cream for most recipes.

Greek yogurt with whole milk, Soy milk and olive oil, milk and butter, coconut milk, half-and-half cream, evaporated milk, cottage cheese and milk, and milk and cornstarch are all excellent heavy whipped cream replacements.

Best Heavy Whipping Cream Substitutes

What makes this even more intriguing is that you may already have one of these substitute products in your refrigerator.

It’s now time to be innovative and frugal.

If you don’t, you should go to the grocery store right now. Don’t be concerned. All of these goods are easily accessible and inexpensive.

Are you prepared? Let’s get this party started!

1. Greek Yogurt and Milk

We’re bringing a more protein-rich option for thickening your favorite soups or sauces. If you can find Greek yogurt made with whole milk, you may add a nutritious touch to almost any meal.

Just combine equal parts Greek yogurt and full milk. Keep in mind that the end product will be thicker than heavy cream. Hence, before completing a 1:1 ratio exchange, add extra milk to thin it down and get a comparable texture.

Unfortunately, the mixture is not suitable for whipping.

Moreover, since yogurt has less fat, don’t expect it to have the same taste and suppleness as heavy cream in sweets or baked items.

2. Coconut Cream

If you’re a vegan, coconut cream is your best option. It’s highly adaptable and has qualities comparable to heavy whipping cream, however the coconut taste will interfere.

If you are too lazy to create your own Coconut cream, the ready-made version is always available.

Nevertheless, you may easily make your own at home with coconut milk.

So, whatever you choose, make a 1:1 change for cooked, sweet, and baked meals.

You may also use it as a delightful topping for desserts or to make coconut ice cream.

3. Milk and Butter

Indeed, milk and butter are a basic combination that may stand in for heavy cream in nearly any recipe.

These are some of the reasons why it will work:

The butter will add fat to the milk, giving it a fat percentage equivalent to heavy cream.

To make 1 cup (237 ml) of heavy cream, thoroughly combine 1 cup (178 ml) milk and 1 cup (57 g) melted butter.

Most individuals will thicken the drink, particularly if using low-fat milk. You may achieve the same thing by adding a tablespoon (8 grams) of flour to the mix.

Remember, this heavy whipped cream alternative should only be used in cooking and baking dishes.

4. Soy Milk and Olive Oil

Dairy-free options include soy milk and olive oil. As a vegan, you will love this blend since your alternatives are restricted.

The olive oil, like the milk and butter mixture, adds fat to the soy milk, making it taste and act like heavy cream.

While the mixture is not suited for whipping, the softness and flavor will meet all of your culinary and baking demands.

1 cup (237 ml) heavy cream may be replaced with 3 cups (159 ml) soy milk. As a result, combine a 1 cup (79 mL) olive oil and a 3 cup (79 mL) olive oil.

5. Milk and Cornstarch

Despite how bad it sounds, mixing milk with cornstarch will bring you closer to the texture of heavy cream.

And it makes no difference whether you use full milk or skim milk; either will help you reduce the calories and fat content of your dish.

Having said that, this is a low-fat, low-calorie option. Nonetheless, it is best suited for cooking.

It will not whip as well as heavy cream. It’s okay for baked items since it may change the texture of the finished product.

To substitute 1 cup (237 ml) of heavy cream in your recipe, whisk together two tablespoons (19 grams) cornstarch and 1 cup (237 ml) milk.

6. Half-And-Half + Butter

In many recipes, half-and-half cream with butter may be used in place of heavy cream.

Half and half is a reasonable alternative, but it’s not quite enough since it only contains approximately a third of the fat of heavy cream.

Yet, combining butter makes it the greatest heavy cream substitute.

Since the butter helps to boost the fat level, the mixture is acceptable for practically any dish that calls for heavy cream, including whipping.

If you’re just concerned with your sauces and soups, you can skip the butter.

8 cup melted butter (29 grams). 8 cup (232 g) half-and-half plus 1 The correct amount for 1 cup (237 ml) of heavy cream replacement is a combination of 7

7. Evaporated Milk

Evaporated milk is the ideal alternative in recipes that call for heavy cream as a liquid component, such as baked goods.

Since it contains 60% less water than conventional milk, this canned, shelf-stable milk is thicker and creamier.

While it does not have the same consistency as heavy cream, it will meet the majority of your demands except for whipping.

All you need to do is swap a 1:1 ratio.

If you’re making a dessert, a few drops of vanilla extract will help bring out the taste.

8. Cottage Cheese and Milk

We begin nutritiously and conclude nutritiously. Cottage cheese is a good source of protein and a variety of minerals. It is manufactured from cow’s milk curds, making it a healthier alternative to heavy cream.

Only it may be used in lieu of heavy cream in dishes such as soups and sauces. Yet, the lumps have always posed a concern. Here is when the milk enters the picture. When combined with milk, it takes on the smooth, creamy texture of heavy cream.

To remove lumps, we suggest mixing it in a food processor or immersion blender.

Unfortunately, this blend is not compatible with all heavy cream recipes. Thus, choose dishes that include its particular cheesy tastes, like as savory sauces and soups. Just combine equal parts cottage cheese and milk in a blender and process until the lumps are gone.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Heavy Cream and Whipping Cream The Same?

Whipping cream is the heavy cream’s identical twin. And, like all identical twins, they seem identical yet are not. Their constancy is what distinguishes them.

Whipping cream is lighter because it has less milk fat, ranging from 30% to 35%. And no pie is complete until it has it! However, heavy cream has a substantially greater milk fat content, at least 36%. You may also produce whipped cream from heavy cream.

The good news is that:

You can’t go wrong using them interchangeably in cooking; the only difference is that your dish’s consistency will alter. Heavy cream yields a thicker, creamier finish than whipping cream.

Keep this in mind!

What Is the Difference Between Heavy Cream and Half And Half?

Half and half is a blend of whole milk and heavy cream. Yet, depending on the cream used, the proportion of fat might range from 10.5% to 18%. Note that the cream includes 36% to 40% fat, which also counts.

Nevertheless, for more information, check our post What Is Half and Half? What is a suitable substitute? Heavy cream, on the other hand, is made by skimming the fat that comes to the top of the milk during processing.

It is a rich, thick, and pourable cream that is used to make various milk products with varying fat concentrations, such as half and half, butter, ice cream, and buttermilk. Nevertheless, heavy whipping cream has a far greater fat content than half and half, giving it a thicker and creamier texture.

 Is there a Vegan Heavy Cream Substitute?

There is, indeed. Since you cannot use any of these dairy products, you may substitute a plant-based cream, such as coconut milk.

Not coconut cream, but coconut milk. Coconut cream tastes like cocktails and is high in sugar. Your best bet is full-fat coconut milk. All you need to do is chill it in the refrigerator for a few hours.

After opening, remove the fat off the top. This may be used in lieu of heavy cream in soups and pasta.

Can you use Cream Cheese instead of heavy whipping cream?

Cream cheese may be substituted for heavy cream in an equivalent proportion. Regrettably, it’s better reserved for thick cream-based soups and sauces than for whipping. Since cream cheese is created from milk and cream, it is also a better choice for frostings.

It’s great as a main element in cheesecakes or as a spread for bagels.

WARNING! You should keep in mind that substituting cream cheese for heavy cream will change the flavor and texture of the final dish. As a result, it is ideal if you stick to appropriate recipes. Don’t go too far!

Conclusion

Bottom line, as long as you keep to the ratios and appropriate recipes, any of the heavy whipping cream alternatives on this website will perform just fine.

Although some may not taste or feel precisely like heavy cream, some are similar. Most even approach the texture and trail behind the taste notes. That is precisely how an alternative appears. You do not anticipate anything like.

Nevertheless, our list is much more diversified, including low-fat or vegan substitutes that are high in protein or low in calories, such as cottage cheese, silken tofu, and Greek yogurt.

Related Articles:

• Can Heavy Whipping Cream Be Used in Instead of Milk?
• What Is the Weight of a Gallon of Milk?
• How to Use Curry Paste in Instead of Coconut Milk
• Is it possible to freeze coconut milk?
• Substitutes for Potato Starch