Posted on
Rate this post

Pork shoulder is a fantastic cut of meat, but not everyone is aware of this flavor-packed pig cut; due to low demand, your local grocery store may run out of pork shoulders more often than you would like.

So, what do you do when you want to make your favorite pork shoulder roast but can’t locate your preferred meat cut? What are the finest pork shoulder replacements?

When you can’t get the genuine thing, boneless pig leg, beef shoulder, beef brisket, and pork butt are some of the closest substitutes.

What’s more, the finest part?

They all strike close to home, giving the same taste and flavor as pork shoulders.

What Is Pork Shoulder?

Pork shoulder is an extremely versatile piece of meat that can be matched with almost anything.

Pork shoulders offer all of the ideal characteristics of a meat cut in terms of size, texture, and taste.

When considering substitutions, keep in mind that not all recipes can accept a substitution; meat cuts also have varied cooking durations, so you would need to customize your recipe to the sort of meat cut you choose.

How Long Does It Take To Cook Pork Shoulder?

A entire hog shoulder must be cooked at low heat for a lengthy amount of time. This prevents the meat from drying out and ensures uniform cooking.

Crisp up the skin of the pork shoulder using your preferred manner before baking it at 350°F for 22 hours. It is ready when the internal temperature of the shoulder reaches at least 145 degrees Fahrenheit.

Best Substitutes For Pork Shoulder

Note that each pig cut has its unique cooking method, which may be longer or shorter than pork shoulders, so modify your recipe appropriately.

1. Pork Butt (Boston Butt)

Two fresh raw boneless pork shoulder butt slices on black stone plate

Pork butt and shoulder are derived from the same pig cutout, but they are not the same. Boston butt is cut from the top section of the pig’s body and is named for the barrels that the pork is placed in.

It’s a great replacement for pork shoulder; in fact, some say it’s even better than pig shoulder. Both cuts need a considerable cooking time and must be cooked slowly.

Pork butt is available in large pieces weighing up to 3 kilograms; when you purchase this cut, you get to remove the bone and chop it into desired proportions.

Since they have comparable fat marbling and form, pork butt may be used in lieu of shoulder cut in practically all slow-cooking recipes. Two cuts are often marketed together and may be braised, stewed, roasted, or grilled.

2. Center Cut Pork Loin Roast

The center cut pork loin roast is a cutting from the pig’s rear leg and shoulder. The flesh is very soft and is a favourite boneless pig component. As compared to other cuts, the meat has a more uniform shape and less fat.

Since it is more tasty and palatable, the bone is frequently removed from the meat before it is sold. This is a lean cut that can survive prolonged high-temperature cooking without coming apart.

It is a low-cost cut that is widely available in marketplaces. This meat cut is obtained from the whole pig loin and is sometimes referred to as a roast due to its size; a single piece may weigh up to 2-4 pounds.

Since their structures are comparable, center cut pork loin roast is an excellent option for hog shoulder. It becomes soft and juicy when properly cooked.

This meat cut is best roasted because of its log form, which is akin to a wrapped pork shoulder; roasting also gives a touch of additional flavor to the meat’s skin.

This meat cut may be prepared similarly to pork shoulders and is an excellent substitute for steaks. It is also ideal for stewing meat and ground pork.

The exterior layer of the beef should be roasted at high heat, at 400°F, for 20-25 minutes. Preparing this piece of meat whole is quite similar to cooking hog shoulders. To begin, crisp up the skin.

When crisped, decrease the temperature to 350°F and continue to roast for 40-50 minutes.

The cooking time for a pork loin cut varies depending on its size, but it cooks quicker than a shoulder cut. This implies that you should constantly keep an eye on the meat while it cooks, particularly if you’re grilling it.

3. Boneless Pork Leg

This is a tasty beef cut that is often used in various cuisines and, like the shoulder cut, requires long cooking. It is a triangular piece of flesh that is sliced from the region above the pig’s front leg.

Pork leg is sometimes called as ham, depending on how the meat is processed; it has very similar properties to shoulder cut.

The flesh from the interior of the hog leg is ideal for almost any pork shoulder substitute. This is the closest section to the pig’s back and has a comparable structure; it may be bone-in or deboned.

But, bear in mind that this meat cut piece gets much drier when cooked since it contains considerably less fat than shoulder sections.

Pig leg is a wonderful replacement for complete hog shoulder, but you must monitor the moisture levels to ensure it keeps the majority of its juiciness.

Cooking this cut is identical to cooking top loin roast; just roast on high heat for 25 minutes, then lower heat and continue cooking for 40-45 minutes, depending on the size of the cut. 1 pound of pig leg flesh should be cooked for 25 minutes as a general guideline.

This leg’s flesh is also delicious roasted and produces superb pulled pork. You may add some sauce to the pulled meat to give moisture and juiciness while masking the dryness.

4. Lamb or Beef Shoulder

If you don’t eat pork, lamb shoulder is an excellent non-pork option for pig shoulder since it’s virtually the same cut but from a different animal. Both beef cuts have comparable properties but vary in flavor.

Lamb has a more gamey flavor than pig, which some people dislike. You may also substitute beef shoulder for the lamb.

Lambs shoulder is an excellent alternative for all hog shoulder cuts and works well in any dish. It may be used in the same manner, marketed in identical shapes and slices, and cooked in the same way.

Lamb offers a variety of tastes and has less fat than beef. As a result, you may need to double-check the recipe to confirm it will work with lamb and make any required changes.

To increase the fattiness of the dish, add oil, butter, or cream; this also adds moisture. A whole lamb may take somewhat longer to cook than hog depending on the brine and temperature employed.

5. Beef Brisket

Several people choose to use lamb instead of beef shoulder because lamb has a distinct taste that beef lacks.

The exception to this rule is beef brisket. When marinated in the correct brine, it absorbs the tastes of the herbs and ingredients extremely effectively, giving it a taste remarkably similar to pork shoulder. You may still need to experiment with your recipe.

Because of its greater moisture content, beef is likewise more difficult to dry out than pig. Since beef shoulder cutout is substantially bigger than pork shoulder cutout, choose a cut that is around the same weight as the pig version required by the recipe.

Beef shoulder may be used in the same meals as hog shoulder, such as steaks, blades, ground beef, wrapped beef shoulder, and so on. Beef brisket can be shredded in the same way as pork shoulder can, making it an excellent replacement for pulled pork.

What Meat Cuts Cannot Be Used as Pork Shoulder Substitute?

Thin slices are not a good alternative for pork shoulder because they lack necessary fat and moisture and cook quicker.

Slow roasting pork shoulder or any alternative takes a long time to let the flavors to emerge, blend, and develop; nevertheless, this technique is not appropriate for meat that cannot simmer for prolonged periods of time.

Loin steak, loin eye steak, fillet, valentine steak, and collar steak are all examples of unacceptable thin cuts.

Related Posts:

  • 9 Excellent Salt Pork Substitutes
  • Top 10 Herbs to Serve with Pork
  • Substitutes for Prosciutto
  • 12 Greatest Pork Belly Substitutes (with Photos)
  • Top 5 Pork Chop Herbs


What is most similar to pork shoulder?

So, what is the finest pork shoulder replacement? Of course, the best alternative for a certain pig shoulder is another pork shoulder. Pork leg (ham), upper loin roast, and upper leg are additional options. Lamb shoulder or sirloin is the finest substitution for non-pork substitutes.

What can I use for pulled pork instead of shoulder?

While hog butt is perfect for barbeque pulled pork, it also lends itself to braising and stewing, which tenderizes the flesh and melts the fat. Pork butt may be used in any dish that calls for fall-apart soft flesh and a rich, porky taste, such as pulled pork, carnitas, or stew.

Can I sub pork loin for pork shoulder?

Can you use pork loin instead of pork shoulder? In most circumstances, you can replace pork loin for pork shoulder and vice versa. Both cuts of beef have a similar flavor. To prevent overcooking the pork loin and undercooking the pork shoulder, just adjust the specified cooking times.

What is the beef equivalent of pork shoulder?

Chuck roast is often regarded as the finest cut for making pulled beef. Chuck roasts, like the front shoulder of pork (or the pig “butt”), are high in fat, collagen, and marbling since they come from the front shoulder of the cow. This is what we’ll need to prepare tender, juicy pulled beef.

What cut of pork makes the best pulled pork?

Pork shoulder is excellent for tugging. It has a high fat content, which results in soft, melty flesh, but it must be cooked slowly to enable the protein to break down correctly.

What is pork shoulder called in grocery store?

The whole front leg and shoulder of a hog is made up of pork shoulder. If you go to your local grocery store, you may expect to see pork shoulder separated into two slices. The pig butt and pork shoulder, often known as the “Boston roast” and “picnic roast,” are the two portions.

Is pork tenderloin good for pulled pork?

What is the greatest kind of meat to use for pulled pork? Pulled pork is often made using pig shoulder or pork butt. For a leaner piece of meat, try using pork tenderloin (as in this dish).

Can you use pork loin for pulled pork?

A boneless pork shoulder or pig butt, often known as Boston butt, is the greatest cut of pork for pulled pork. After pressure cooking, these pig chops have lots of fat marbled throughout for taste, and they become fall apart tender. You may also create pulled pork using a pig loin.

What is the secret to tender pulled pork?

The key to the juiciest and most tender pulled pork is to cook it low and slow. Serve the pork as is, or at the conclusion of cooking, toss with your favorite barbecue or other sauces.

What is pork shoulder alternative names?

Picnic roast, Boston butt, blade roast, and pig butt are all names for pork shoulder in the grocery shop. Braising, smoking, roasting, grilling, and slow cooking are all common ways to prepare pork shoulder. Cook the pork shoulder for 6-8 hours on low or 4-5 hours on high.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *